In Kevin Costner Presents: The First Christmas (2026), a new lens is cast on one of the world’s most profound stories—the birth of Jesus Christ. Set against the backdrop of Bethlehem under Roman rule, this historical epic blends spiritual drama with human mystery, exploring the events surrounding that fateful night in a grounded and reverent way. The film centers on Reuben (Kevin Costner), a former temple scribe turned investigator, who is tasked with uncovering the truth behind rumors of a miraculous birth. Skeptical and driven by logic, Reuben approaches his investigation through a lens of facts and reason, dismissing faith as something beyond his understanding. However, what begins as a quest for certainty soon turns into a journey of profound reckoning.
Bethlehem is alive with activity as the Roman census fills the streets with travelers, whispers of prophecy, and an undercurrent of fear. Soldiers patrol the torch-lit city, keeping order amid the chaos. But above all of this, a mysterious star appears—steady, brilliant, and inexplicable, a symbol that calls for attention in the night sky. Reuben, drawn into the intrigue, believes he can decipher the truth using documents and testimonies, but his journey will challenge everything he knows about belief, logic, and the unspoken mysteries of the world.
Crossing paths with Mary (Jennifer Connelly) and Joseph (Oscar Isaac), Reuben finds himself drawn to two figures who are far from the grandiose figures one might expect. Rather than preachers or individuals seeking attention, Mary and Joseph are humble, unassuming, and largely quiet, silently enduring their extraordinary role in history. Reuben’s investigation gradually reveals their quiet presence in the greater narrative, slowly peeling back layers of their humanity and the profound silence that surrounds them.
The film’s haunting beauty is found in the delicate balance between skepticism and faith. Reuben’s search for historical accuracy begins to collide with undeniable truths. As he interviews shepherds and searches through records, his certainty begins to erode. His investigation becomes increasingly entangled with voices that challenge his assumptions. Shohreh Aghdashloo plays a resolute woman whose testimony cannot be ignored, pushing Reuben to reconsider his stance. Ben Kingsley portrays a learned elder, suggesting that history’s greatest shifts often occur without grand declarations or public attention, in the most humble corners of the world.
The quiet tension builds as Reuben uncovers more than he bargained for. What started as a simple investigation into a rumored birth becomes a personal journey—a confrontation with a truth beyond logic and reason. The stable outside Bethlehem, where no spectacle is made, no proclamation is shouted, becomes the site where time itself is reshaped. The humble birth of a child—a child who will one day change the world—is at the center of it all.
Kevin Costner Presents: The First Christmas is an extraordinary retelling of the Nativity, one that explores doubt, moral conflict, and historical realism in a way that honors faith without preaching. It’s a story of belief in its most profound and personal form, told not through grand speeches or magical elements, but through the quiet, human moments that define the Christmas story.
Costner’s performance as Reuben brings a grounded, conflicted depth to the character. His journey from skeptic to believer is compelling and nuanced, offering a portrayal that is as human as it is spiritual. Jennifer Connelly and Oscar Isaac as Mary and Joseph bring a calm, powerful presence to their roles, embodying the quiet strength and humility that are central to the story. The film is as much about their understated journey as it is about Reuben’s awakening to the unimaginable power of faith and grace.
Verdict: ★★★★★ (10/10) — Kevin Costner Presents: The First Christmas is a beautiful, haunting, and introspective reimagining of the Nativity story. With exceptional performances, stunning cinematography, and a respectful, thought-provoking narrative, the film captures the mystery and wonder of the Christmas story in a way that will resonate with audiences of all faiths. This is a must-see holiday epic that reminds us of the quiet power of belief and the extraordinary impact of a single, humble birth. ✨🕯️ #
Watch movie:
*Content is hosted on a partner site.
