In KEVIN COSTNER PRESENTS: THE FIRST CHRISTMAS, the world’s most significant story is told with an unexpected, grounded approach. Rather than a grandiose retelling filled with angels and proclamations, this film invites viewers to witness the birth of Christ through the eyes of Reuben (Kevin Costner), a man bound by logic and reason, whose quest to uncover the truth behind a miraculous birth forces him to confront the very limits of human knowledge and belief.
The film opens not with a burst of divine light but with a quiet, contemplative atmosphere that lingers throughout. Reuben is tasked with investigating the mysterious rumors of a miraculous child born in a humble stable, a story that has begun to spread like wildfire. As a man of reason, he cannot accept the idea of a divine birth without concrete evidence. This investigation, however, takes him on an unexpected journey, one that challenges not just the facts, but the very fabric of his belief system. Kevin Costner’s portrayal of Reuben is powerful and nuanced, capturing a man torn between skepticism and an emerging sense of wonder.
What stands out in this version of the Nativity is its focus on the simplicity and human complexity of the story. Rather than focusing on the divine nature of the birth, The First Christmas places the story in the hands of the ordinary people involved — Mary (Jennifer Connelly) and Joseph (Oscar Isaac). These two characters, often seen in grandiose terms as holy figures, are instead depicted as humble, devoted individuals simply trying to care for a child who will change the world. Their reluctance to claim any divine status for their child adds a layer of humility and realism to the narrative that feels strikingly intimate.
Oscar Isaac’s portrayal of Joseph is gentle yet steadfast, a man unwilling to claim the mantle of greatness despite the world’s insistence that his son is the Messiah. Connelly’s Mary is equally compelling, embodying both strength and vulnerability as she quietly navigates the weight of a world that is growing more suspicious and curious about her son. Together, they form the emotional core of the film, with their quiet resilience and unwillingness to proclaim divine knowledge creating a deeply moving portrayal of faith.
As Reuben delves deeper into the mystery of the birth, he encounters a series of characters that challenge his worldview. One of the most notable is the elder, played by Ben Kingsley, whose wisdom and enigmatic demeanor push Reuben to reconsider his assumptions about truth and knowledge. Kingsley’s performance is striking in its quiet authority, and his character serves as a foil to Reuben’s logic-driven perspective. Alongside him is Shohreh Aghdashloo, who portrays a resolute woman whose own experiences with faith and doubt bring further depth to Reuben’s understanding of the human experience.
The film’s pacing is deliberate and reflective, allowing the audience to experience the journey of discovery alongside Reuben. It’s not about fast-paced action or sudden revelations; rather, it’s a slow unraveling of truths, each one more profound than the last. As Reuben unravels the contradictions and gaps in the accounts of the birth, he must confront his own internal doubts, questioning whether faith can ever be justified by logic or if, perhaps, it exists beyond human comprehension altogether.
The cinematography is breathtaking, with sweeping shots of the desert landscape, contrasted against the intimacy of small, humble interiors. The contrast between the vast, uncaring world and the personal, intimate moments between the characters enhances the film’s central themes of isolation, doubt, and connection. The film’s quiet tone is punctuated by moments of visual beauty — the stars in the sky, the flickering of firelight — reminding the viewer that sometimes the most profound moments in life are not the loud, spectacular ones, but the small, hidden ones that pass unnoticed.
This is not a film that answers all questions or provides a neat resolution to its theological themes. Instead, it asks a question that resonates deeply: What if the most significant event in human history didn’t arrive with absolute certainty, but with a quiet, unspoken doubt? What if belief itself was the answer, not the certainty of its proof? The First Christmas challenges its audience to consider faith not as something that can be proven, but as something that must be felt and experienced.
The narrative is enriched by the philosophical questions it raises about the nature of truth, belief, and doubt. It’s a human story that transcends religious boundaries, inviting viewers to reflect on their own relationships with faith. Can a person find meaning in the unknown? Is there room for doubt in the pursuit of truth? These questions are not answered directly, but through the quiet moments of Reuben’s journey, they resonate deeply.
Costner’s involvement in the project adds an extra layer of gravitas, with his direction and performance providing a grounded, thoughtful exploration of the Nativity. His portrayal of Reuben is one of emotional restraint, giving space for the quieter moments to have the greatest impact. There’s a sense of emotional authenticity in his performance that anchors the film’s more philosophical themes in reality.
The supporting cast, particularly Aghdashloo and Kingsley, bring immense depth to the narrative, creating characters who serve as both guides and obstacles in Reuben’s journey. Their performances offer insights into the complexity of human emotion — the interplay of faith, reason, and the unknown.
In conclusion, KEVIN COSTNER PRESENTS: THE FIRST CHRISTMAS is a deeply thoughtful, introspective retelling of the Nativity story that focuses on the human uncertainty that often precedes belief. With powerful performances from Costner, Connelly, Isaac, and an exceptional supporting cast, the film challenges viewers to consider the nature of faith itself. This is a film that asks us to question not just the certainty of our beliefs, but the quiet doubt that shapes them. It is, above all, a story about the profound mysteries that lie at the heart of the human experience.
Watch movie:
*Content is hosted on a partner site.
